The Elusive Quest for Digital Exhaustion in the US and the EU The CJEU’s Tom Kabinet Ruling a Milestone or Millstone for Legal Evolution?

Shubha Ghosh, Péter Mezei

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articlepeer-review

2 Scopus citations

Abstract

The CJEU published its much-awaited preliminary ruling in Case C-263/18-Nederlands Uitgeversverbond and Groep Algemene Uitgevers (the Tom Kabinet case) in December 2019. Our paper aims to introduce the Tom Kabinet ruling and discuss its direct and indirect consequences in copyright law. The Tom Kabinet ruling has seriously limited (in fact, outruled) the resale of lawfully acquired e-books. It left various questions unanswered, and thus missed the opportunity to provide for clarity and consistency in digital copyright law. Our analysis addresses how the CJEU deferred from its own logic developed in the UsedSoft decision on the resale of lawfully acquired computer programs, and how the CJEU’s conservative approach ultimately missed the opportunity to reach a compromise ruling. The paper further introduces the US approach that has a strong distinction between selling and making with respect to the research of exhaustion. We aim to trace how this distinction rests on the statutory basis for exhaustion (in copyright) and common law basis (in patent and trademark law) and compare these findings with the CJEU’s recent interpretation of exhaustion. Our focus will be on the Supreme Court’s decisions in Kirstaeng and Bowman and lower court decisions that examine technological solutions to facilitate resale. We examine how the US approach adopts a rigid approach that might inhibit technological development in digital markets, an approach with parallels in the Tom Kabinet ruling. In conclusion, we assess whether there is convergence between the two sides of the Atlantic or whether there is a path of innovative legal development that reconciles the various precedents.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)249-275
Number of pages27
JournalHungarian Yearbook of International Law and European Law
Volume8
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 2020

Keywords

  • ReDigi
  • Tom Kabinet
  • UsedSoft
  • copyright law
  • digital exhaustion

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Law

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'The Elusive Quest for Digital Exhaustion in the US and the EU The CJEU’s Tom Kabinet Ruling a Milestone or Millstone for Legal Evolution?'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this