The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts

W. Fong, E. Berger, P. K. Blanchard, R. Margutti, P. S. Cowperthwaite, R. Chornock, K. D. Alexander, B. D. Metzger, V. A. Villar, M. Nicholl, T. Eftekhari, P. K.G. Williams, J. Annis, D. Brout, Duncan Brown, H. Y. Chen, Z. Doctor, H. T. Diehl, D. E. Holz, A. Rest & 2 others M. Sako, M. Soares-Santos

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

45 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We present a comprehensive comparison of the properties of the radio through X-ray counterpart of GW170817 and the properties of short-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). For this effort, we utilize a sample of 36 short GRBs spanning a redshift range of z ≈ 0.12-2.6 discovered over 2004-2017. We find that the counterpart to GW170817 has an isotropic-equivalent luminosity that is ≈ 3000 times less than the median value of on-axis short GRB X-ray afterglows, and ≳104 times less than that for detected short GRB radio afterglows. Moreover, the allowed jet energies and particle densities inferred from the radio and X-ray counterparts to GW170817 and on-axis short GRB afterglows are remarkably similar, suggesting that viewing angle effects are the dominant, and perhaps only, difference in their observed radio and X-ray behavior. From comparison to previous claimed kilonovae following short GRBs, we find that the optical and near-infrared (NIR) counterpart to GW170817 is comparatively under-luminous by a factor of ≈3-5, indicating a range of kilonova luminosities and timescales. A comparison of the optical limits following short GRBs on ≲1 day timescales also rules out a "blue" kilonova of comparable optical isotropic-equivalent luminosity in one previous short GRB. Finally, we investigate the host galaxy of GW170817, NGC 4993, in the context of short GRB host galaxy stellar population properties. We find that NGC 4993 is superlative in terms of its large luminosity, old stellar population age, and low star formation rate compared to previous short GRB hosts. Additional events within the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO)/Virgo volume will be crucial in delineating the properties of the host galaxies of neutron star-neutron star (NS-NS) mergers, and connecting them to their cosmological counterparts.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article numberL23
JournalAstrophysical Journal Letters
Volume848
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 20 2017

Fingerprint

LIGO (observatory)
binary stars
interferometer
gamma ray bursts
merger
neutron stars
observatory
laser
radio
electromagnetism
timescale
afterglows
luminosity
near infrared
galaxies
x rays
comparison
stellar luminosity
energy
star formation rate

Keywords

  • gamma-ray burst: general
  • gravitational waves
  • stars: neutron

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
  • Space and Planetary Science

Cite this

The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts. / Fong, W.; Berger, E.; Blanchard, P. K.; Margutti, R.; Cowperthwaite, P. S.; Chornock, R.; Alexander, K. D.; Metzger, B. D.; Villar, V. A.; Nicholl, M.; Eftekhari, T.; Williams, P. K.G.; Annis, J.; Brout, D.; Brown, Duncan; Chen, H. Y.; Doctor, Z.; Diehl, H. T.; Holz, D. E.; Rest, A.; Sako, M.; Soares-Santos, M.

In: Astrophysical Journal Letters, Vol. 848, No. 2, L23, 20.10.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Fong, W, Berger, E, Blanchard, PK, Margutti, R, Cowperthwaite, PS, Chornock, R, Alexander, KD, Metzger, BD, Villar, VA, Nicholl, M, Eftekhari, T, Williams, PKG, Annis, J, Brout, D, Brown, D, Chen, HY, Doctor, Z, Diehl, HT, Holz, DE, Rest, A, Sako, M & Soares-Santos, M 2017, 'The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts', Astrophysical Journal Letters, vol. 848, no. 2, L23. https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018
Fong, W. ; Berger, E. ; Blanchard, P. K. ; Margutti, R. ; Cowperthwaite, P. S. ; Chornock, R. ; Alexander, K. D. ; Metzger, B. D. ; Villar, V. A. ; Nicholl, M. ; Eftekhari, T. ; Williams, P. K.G. ; Annis, J. ; Brout, D. ; Brown, Duncan ; Chen, H. Y. ; Doctor, Z. ; Diehl, H. T. ; Holz, D. E. ; Rest, A. ; Sako, M. ; Soares-Santos, M. / The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts. In: Astrophysical Journal Letters. 2017 ; Vol. 848, No. 2.
@article{ee42a05139de4eabb45ecf4f07e3c2f6,
title = "The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts",
abstract = "We present a comprehensive comparison of the properties of the radio through X-ray counterpart of GW170817 and the properties of short-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). For this effort, we utilize a sample of 36 short GRBs spanning a redshift range of z ≈ 0.12-2.6 discovered over 2004-2017. We find that the counterpart to GW170817 has an isotropic-equivalent luminosity that is ≈ 3000 times less than the median value of on-axis short GRB X-ray afterglows, and ≳104 times less than that for detected short GRB radio afterglows. Moreover, the allowed jet energies and particle densities inferred from the radio and X-ray counterparts to GW170817 and on-axis short GRB afterglows are remarkably similar, suggesting that viewing angle effects are the dominant, and perhaps only, difference in their observed radio and X-ray behavior. From comparison to previous claimed kilonovae following short GRBs, we find that the optical and near-infrared (NIR) counterpart to GW170817 is comparatively under-luminous by a factor of ≈3-5, indicating a range of kilonova luminosities and timescales. A comparison of the optical limits following short GRBs on ≲1 day timescales also rules out a {"}blue{"} kilonova of comparable optical isotropic-equivalent luminosity in one previous short GRB. Finally, we investigate the host galaxy of GW170817, NGC 4993, in the context of short GRB host galaxy stellar population properties. We find that NGC 4993 is superlative in terms of its large luminosity, old stellar population age, and low star formation rate compared to previous short GRB hosts. Additional events within the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO)/Virgo volume will be crucial in delineating the properties of the host galaxies of neutron star-neutron star (NS-NS) mergers, and connecting them to their cosmological counterparts.",
keywords = "gamma-ray burst: general, gravitational waves, stars: neutron",
author = "W. Fong and E. Berger and Blanchard, {P. K.} and R. Margutti and Cowperthwaite, {P. S.} and R. Chornock and Alexander, {K. D.} and Metzger, {B. D.} and Villar, {V. A.} and M. Nicholl and T. Eftekhari and Williams, {P. K.G.} and J. Annis and D. Brout and Duncan Brown and Chen, {H. Y.} and Z. Doctor and Diehl, {H. T.} and Holz, {D. E.} and A. Rest and M. Sako and M. Soares-Santos",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
day = "20",
doi = "10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "848",
journal = "Astrophysical Journal Letters",
issn = "2041-8205",
publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts

AU - Fong, W.

AU - Berger, E.

AU - Blanchard, P. K.

AU - Margutti, R.

AU - Cowperthwaite, P. S.

AU - Chornock, R.

AU - Alexander, K. D.

AU - Metzger, B. D.

AU - Villar, V. A.

AU - Nicholl, M.

AU - Eftekhari, T.

AU - Williams, P. K.G.

AU - Annis, J.

AU - Brout, D.

AU - Brown, Duncan

AU - Chen, H. Y.

AU - Doctor, Z.

AU - Diehl, H. T.

AU - Holz, D. E.

AU - Rest, A.

AU - Sako, M.

AU - Soares-Santos, M.

PY - 2017/10/20

Y1 - 2017/10/20

N2 - We present a comprehensive comparison of the properties of the radio through X-ray counterpart of GW170817 and the properties of short-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). For this effort, we utilize a sample of 36 short GRBs spanning a redshift range of z ≈ 0.12-2.6 discovered over 2004-2017. We find that the counterpart to GW170817 has an isotropic-equivalent luminosity that is ≈ 3000 times less than the median value of on-axis short GRB X-ray afterglows, and ≳104 times less than that for detected short GRB radio afterglows. Moreover, the allowed jet energies and particle densities inferred from the radio and X-ray counterparts to GW170817 and on-axis short GRB afterglows are remarkably similar, suggesting that viewing angle effects are the dominant, and perhaps only, difference in their observed radio and X-ray behavior. From comparison to previous claimed kilonovae following short GRBs, we find that the optical and near-infrared (NIR) counterpart to GW170817 is comparatively under-luminous by a factor of ≈3-5, indicating a range of kilonova luminosities and timescales. A comparison of the optical limits following short GRBs on ≲1 day timescales also rules out a "blue" kilonova of comparable optical isotropic-equivalent luminosity in one previous short GRB. Finally, we investigate the host galaxy of GW170817, NGC 4993, in the context of short GRB host galaxy stellar population properties. We find that NGC 4993 is superlative in terms of its large luminosity, old stellar population age, and low star formation rate compared to previous short GRB hosts. Additional events within the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO)/Virgo volume will be crucial in delineating the properties of the host galaxies of neutron star-neutron star (NS-NS) mergers, and connecting them to their cosmological counterparts.

AB - We present a comprehensive comparison of the properties of the radio through X-ray counterpart of GW170817 and the properties of short-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). For this effort, we utilize a sample of 36 short GRBs spanning a redshift range of z ≈ 0.12-2.6 discovered over 2004-2017. We find that the counterpart to GW170817 has an isotropic-equivalent luminosity that is ≈ 3000 times less than the median value of on-axis short GRB X-ray afterglows, and ≳104 times less than that for detected short GRB radio afterglows. Moreover, the allowed jet energies and particle densities inferred from the radio and X-ray counterparts to GW170817 and on-axis short GRB afterglows are remarkably similar, suggesting that viewing angle effects are the dominant, and perhaps only, difference in their observed radio and X-ray behavior. From comparison to previous claimed kilonovae following short GRBs, we find that the optical and near-infrared (NIR) counterpart to GW170817 is comparatively under-luminous by a factor of ≈3-5, indicating a range of kilonova luminosities and timescales. A comparison of the optical limits following short GRBs on ≲1 day timescales also rules out a "blue" kilonova of comparable optical isotropic-equivalent luminosity in one previous short GRB. Finally, we investigate the host galaxy of GW170817, NGC 4993, in the context of short GRB host galaxy stellar population properties. We find that NGC 4993 is superlative in terms of its large luminosity, old stellar population age, and low star formation rate compared to previous short GRB hosts. Additional events within the Advanced Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO)/Virgo volume will be crucial in delineating the properties of the host galaxies of neutron star-neutron star (NS-NS) mergers, and connecting them to their cosmological counterparts.

KW - gamma-ray burst: general

KW - gravitational waves

KW - stars: neutron

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85032016274&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85032016274&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018

DO - 10.3847/2041-8213/aa9018

M3 - Article

VL - 848

JO - Astrophysical Journal Letters

JF - Astrophysical Journal Letters

SN - 2041-8205

IS - 2

M1 - L23

ER -