Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird

Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Galápagos

Mariana Bulgarella, Sarah Knutie, Margaret A. Voss, Francesca Cunninghame, Philip Lester, George Heimpel, Charlotte Causton

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

Philornis downsi is a bird-parasitic fly native to mainland South America that invaded the Galapagos Islands where it is pushing some Darwin’s Finch species over the brink of extinction. Flies lay eggs in bird nests and the larvae feed on nestlings, often killing them. Protecting Galapagos landbirds from this parasite is a conservation priority. A short-term solution involves providing permethrin-treated cotton to the finches or injecting wild nests with permethrin. However, the risk of permethrin to long-term bird health and reproduction has not been formally tested. Our experiment represents a worst-case scenario to determine the effects of exposure to permethrin in Zebra Finches (Taeniopygia guttata) across consecutive generations. The experiment consisted of two treatments. Treatment finches received nesting material sprayed with 1% solution of permethrin and control finches received nesting material sham-fumigated with water. The parental generation laid two clutches of eggs (F1.1 and F1.2). Adults reared from the F1.1 clutch were used to establish a second generation (F2). Blood was drawn to evaluate liver function by assaying aspartate aminotransferase and bile acids levels. Permethrin treatment affected hatching mass for both the F1 and F2 generations. Birds exposed to permethrin produced smaller nestlings than controls. The F2 control birds hatched all nestlings, whereas F2 treatment pairs only fledged 70% of nestlings. Treatment had no effect on liver function tests for any generation. While permethrin exposure had some detrimental effects on finch health, the risk of using permethrin on small birds in the field is minimal compared to the rate of nestling death caused by Philornis downsi.
Original languageEnglish (US)
StatePublished - Jun 1 2019
Event2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand - Brentwood Hotel, Kilbirnie, New Zealand
Duration: Jun 1 2019Jun 3 2019
https://www.osnz.org.nz/civicrm/event/info?id=14&reset=1

Conference

Conference2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand
CountryNew Zealand
CityKilbirnie
Period6/1/196/3/19
Internet address

Fingerprint

permethrin
risk assessment
parasites
birds
Taeniopygia guttata
liver function
nests
Galapagos Islands
bird control
bile acids
aspartate transaminase
egg masses
extinction
cotton
hatching
nestlings
death
larvae
blood

Cite this

Bulgarella, M., Knutie, S., Voss, M. A., Cunninghame, F., Lester, P., Heimpel, G., & Causton, C. (2019). Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird: Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Galápagos. Paper presented at 2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand, Kilbirnie, New Zealand.

Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird : Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Galápagos. / Bulgarella, Mariana; Knutie, Sarah; Voss, Margaret A.; Cunninghame, Francesca ; Lester, Philip; Heimpel, George ; Causton, Charlotte.

2019. Paper presented at 2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand, Kilbirnie, New Zealand.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Bulgarella, M, Knutie, S, Voss, MA, Cunninghame, F, Lester, P, Heimpel, G & Causton, C 2019, 'Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird: Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Galápagos' Paper presented at 2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand, Kilbirnie, New Zealand, 6/1/19 - 6/3/19, .
Bulgarella M, Knutie S, Voss MA, Cunninghame F, Lester P, Heimpel G et al. Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird: Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Galápagos. 2019. Paper presented at 2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand, Kilbirnie, New Zealand.
Bulgarella, Mariana ; Knutie, Sarah ; Voss, Margaret A. ; Cunninghame, Francesca ; Lester, Philip ; Heimpel, George ; Causton, Charlotte. / Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird : Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Galápagos. Paper presented at 2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand, Kilbirnie, New Zealand.
@conference{5ea9eb99290c4fd7b5f577a3bf840228,
title = "Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird: Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Gal{\'a}pagos",
abstract = "Philornis downsi is a bird-parasitic fly native to mainland South America that invaded the Galapagos Islands where it is pushing some Darwin’s Finch species over the brink of extinction. Flies lay eggs in bird nests and the larvae feed on nestlings, often killing them. Protecting Galapagos landbirds from this parasite is a conservation priority. A short-term solution involves providing permethrin-treated cotton to the finches or injecting wild nests with permethrin. However, the risk of permethrin to long-term bird health and reproduction has not been formally tested. Our experiment represents a worst-case scenario to determine the effects of exposure to permethrin in Zebra Finches (Taeniopygia guttata) across consecutive generations. The experiment consisted of two treatments. Treatment finches received nesting material sprayed with 1{\%} solution of permethrin and control finches received nesting material sham-fumigated with water. The parental generation laid two clutches of eggs (F1.1 and F1.2). Adults reared from the F1.1 clutch were used to establish a second generation (F2). Blood was drawn to evaluate liver function by assaying aspartate aminotransferase and bile acids levels. Permethrin treatment affected hatching mass for both the F1 and F2 generations. Birds exposed to permethrin produced smaller nestlings than controls. The F2 control birds hatched all nestlings, whereas F2 treatment pairs only fledged 70{\%} of nestlings. Treatment had no effect on liver function tests for any generation. While permethrin exposure had some detrimental effects on finch health, the risk of using permethrin on small birds in the field is minimal compared to the rate of nestling death caused by Philornis downsi.",
author = "Mariana Bulgarella and Sarah Knutie and Voss, {Margaret A.} and Francesca Cunninghame and Philip Lester and George Heimpel and Charlotte Causton",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
note = "2019 Annual General Meeting of The Ornithological Society of New Zealand ; Conference date: 01-06-2019 Through 03-06-2019",
url = "https://www.osnz.org.nz/civicrm/event/info?id=14&reset=1",

}

TY - CONF

T1 - Risk assessment of permethrin exposure on a passerine bird

T2 - Implications to protect Darwin’s Finches from an avian parasite in Galápagos

AU - Bulgarella, Mariana

AU - Knutie, Sarah

AU - Voss, Margaret A.

AU - Cunninghame, Francesca

AU - Lester, Philip

AU - Heimpel, George

AU - Causton, Charlotte

PY - 2019/6/1

Y1 - 2019/6/1

N2 - Philornis downsi is a bird-parasitic fly native to mainland South America that invaded the Galapagos Islands where it is pushing some Darwin’s Finch species over the brink of extinction. Flies lay eggs in bird nests and the larvae feed on nestlings, often killing them. Protecting Galapagos landbirds from this parasite is a conservation priority. A short-term solution involves providing permethrin-treated cotton to the finches or injecting wild nests with permethrin. However, the risk of permethrin to long-term bird health and reproduction has not been formally tested. Our experiment represents a worst-case scenario to determine the effects of exposure to permethrin in Zebra Finches (Taeniopygia guttata) across consecutive generations. The experiment consisted of two treatments. Treatment finches received nesting material sprayed with 1% solution of permethrin and control finches received nesting material sham-fumigated with water. The parental generation laid two clutches of eggs (F1.1 and F1.2). Adults reared from the F1.1 clutch were used to establish a second generation (F2). Blood was drawn to evaluate liver function by assaying aspartate aminotransferase and bile acids levels. Permethrin treatment affected hatching mass for both the F1 and F2 generations. Birds exposed to permethrin produced smaller nestlings than controls. The F2 control birds hatched all nestlings, whereas F2 treatment pairs only fledged 70% of nestlings. Treatment had no effect on liver function tests for any generation. While permethrin exposure had some detrimental effects on finch health, the risk of using permethrin on small birds in the field is minimal compared to the rate of nestling death caused by Philornis downsi.

AB - Philornis downsi is a bird-parasitic fly native to mainland South America that invaded the Galapagos Islands where it is pushing some Darwin’s Finch species over the brink of extinction. Flies lay eggs in bird nests and the larvae feed on nestlings, often killing them. Protecting Galapagos landbirds from this parasite is a conservation priority. A short-term solution involves providing permethrin-treated cotton to the finches or injecting wild nests with permethrin. However, the risk of permethrin to long-term bird health and reproduction has not been formally tested. Our experiment represents a worst-case scenario to determine the effects of exposure to permethrin in Zebra Finches (Taeniopygia guttata) across consecutive generations. The experiment consisted of two treatments. Treatment finches received nesting material sprayed with 1% solution of permethrin and control finches received nesting material sham-fumigated with water. The parental generation laid two clutches of eggs (F1.1 and F1.2). Adults reared from the F1.1 clutch were used to establish a second generation (F2). Blood was drawn to evaluate liver function by assaying aspartate aminotransferase and bile acids levels. Permethrin treatment affected hatching mass for both the F1 and F2 generations. Birds exposed to permethrin produced smaller nestlings than controls. The F2 control birds hatched all nestlings, whereas F2 treatment pairs only fledged 70% of nestlings. Treatment had no effect on liver function tests for any generation. While permethrin exposure had some detrimental effects on finch health, the risk of using permethrin on small birds in the field is minimal compared to the rate of nestling death caused by Philornis downsi.

M3 - Paper

ER -