Let us begin by stating that it is difficult to provide an adequate response that will enlighten the audience if the correspondent neither provides the necessary references nor the details of his computations that are in disagreement with the authors. Since science is evidence based, it is difficult to respond intelligently where evidence of a disagreement is missing. We will respond to Dr. Kimber's comments by addressing each paragraph separately.
ASJC Scopus subject areas
- Condensed Matter Physics
- Electrical and Electronic Engineering