Locating the problem within

Race, learning disabilities, and science

Justin Freedman, Beth A Ferri

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background/Context: In this paper we draw on an intersectional critical framework to analyze and account for the simultaneous interworkings of race and dis/ability. Specifically, we draw on this framework to examine two aims of modern science: (a) to identify distinct biological markers of race and (b) to locate biological and neurological origins of Learning Disabilities (LD). These aims persist despite evidence that both race and LD are socially and politically constructed categories. Purpose/Objective: By reviewing historical and contemporary attempts by researchers to locate race and LD as immutable features embodied by individuals, we reveal how the science behind these categories shares similar underlying systems of logic; both efforts attempt to locate social problems within bodies and illustrate what Samuels (2014) calls "fantasies of identification," or culturally embedded desires to definitively identify and categorize bodies. Research Design: This is a historical analysis Conclusions/Recommendations: We assert the need to engage with intersectional analyses, not simply as demographic variables along the lines of identity categories, but as an analytical tool for uncovering underlying logics that undergird systems of oppression. Examining the shared scientific explanations of race and learning disabilities illuminates possibilities for rethinking key issues at the intersection of race and disability.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalTeachers College Record
Volume119
Issue number5
StatePublished - 2017

Fingerprint

learning disability
science
historical analysis
Social Problems
oppression
research planning
disability
ability
evidence

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education

Cite this

Locating the problem within : Race, learning disabilities, and science. / Freedman, Justin; Ferri, Beth A.

In: Teachers College Record, Vol. 119, No. 5, 2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{976e309fcb9c485095ddd65667a5243d,
title = "Locating the problem within: Race, learning disabilities, and science",
abstract = "Background/Context: In this paper we draw on an intersectional critical framework to analyze and account for the simultaneous interworkings of race and dis/ability. Specifically, we draw on this framework to examine two aims of modern science: (a) to identify distinct biological markers of race and (b) to locate biological and neurological origins of Learning Disabilities (LD). These aims persist despite evidence that both race and LD are socially and politically constructed categories. Purpose/Objective: By reviewing historical and contemporary attempts by researchers to locate race and LD as immutable features embodied by individuals, we reveal how the science behind these categories shares similar underlying systems of logic; both efforts attempt to locate social problems within bodies and illustrate what Samuels (2014) calls {"}fantasies of identification,{"} or culturally embedded desires to definitively identify and categorize bodies. Research Design: This is a historical analysis Conclusions/Recommendations: We assert the need to engage with intersectional analyses, not simply as demographic variables along the lines of identity categories, but as an analytical tool for uncovering underlying logics that undergird systems of oppression. Examining the shared scientific explanations of race and learning disabilities illuminates possibilities for rethinking key issues at the intersection of race and disability.",
author = "Justin Freedman and Ferri, {Beth A}",
year = "2017",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "119",
journal = "Teachers College Record",
issn = "0161-4681",
publisher = "Teachers College Record",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Locating the problem within

T2 - Race, learning disabilities, and science

AU - Freedman, Justin

AU - Ferri, Beth A

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Background/Context: In this paper we draw on an intersectional critical framework to analyze and account for the simultaneous interworkings of race and dis/ability. Specifically, we draw on this framework to examine two aims of modern science: (a) to identify distinct biological markers of race and (b) to locate biological and neurological origins of Learning Disabilities (LD). These aims persist despite evidence that both race and LD are socially and politically constructed categories. Purpose/Objective: By reviewing historical and contemporary attempts by researchers to locate race and LD as immutable features embodied by individuals, we reveal how the science behind these categories shares similar underlying systems of logic; both efforts attempt to locate social problems within bodies and illustrate what Samuels (2014) calls "fantasies of identification," or culturally embedded desires to definitively identify and categorize bodies. Research Design: This is a historical analysis Conclusions/Recommendations: We assert the need to engage with intersectional analyses, not simply as demographic variables along the lines of identity categories, but as an analytical tool for uncovering underlying logics that undergird systems of oppression. Examining the shared scientific explanations of race and learning disabilities illuminates possibilities for rethinking key issues at the intersection of race and disability.

AB - Background/Context: In this paper we draw on an intersectional critical framework to analyze and account for the simultaneous interworkings of race and dis/ability. Specifically, we draw on this framework to examine two aims of modern science: (a) to identify distinct biological markers of race and (b) to locate biological and neurological origins of Learning Disabilities (LD). These aims persist despite evidence that both race and LD are socially and politically constructed categories. Purpose/Objective: By reviewing historical and contemporary attempts by researchers to locate race and LD as immutable features embodied by individuals, we reveal how the science behind these categories shares similar underlying systems of logic; both efforts attempt to locate social problems within bodies and illustrate what Samuels (2014) calls "fantasies of identification," or culturally embedded desires to definitively identify and categorize bodies. Research Design: This is a historical analysis Conclusions/Recommendations: We assert the need to engage with intersectional analyses, not simply as demographic variables along the lines of identity categories, but as an analytical tool for uncovering underlying logics that undergird systems of oppression. Examining the shared scientific explanations of race and learning disabilities illuminates possibilities for rethinking key issues at the intersection of race and disability.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85019008945&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85019008945&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 119

JO - Teachers College Record

JF - Teachers College Record

SN - 0161-4681

IS - 5

ER -