Line transect surveys underdetect terrestrial mammals: Implications for the sustainability of subsistence hunting

Jose M V Fragoso, Taal Levi, Luiz F B Oliveira, Jeffrey B. Luzar, Han Overman, Jane M Read, Kirsten M. Silvius

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

25 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Conservation of Neotropical game species must take into account the livelihood and food security needs of local human populations. Hunting management decisions should therefore rely on abundance and distribution data that are as representative as possible of true population sizes and dynamics. We simultaneously applied a commonly used encounterbased method and an infrequently used sign-based method to estimate hunted vertebrate abundance in a 48,000-km2 indigenous landscape in southern Guyana. Diurnal direct encounter data collected during three years along 216, four-kilometer -long transects consistently under-detected many diurnal and nocturnal mammal species readily detected through sign. Of 32 species analyzed, 31 were detected by both methods; however, encounters did not detect one and under-detected another 12 of the most heavily hunted species relative to sign, while sign under-detected 12 never or rarely collected species relative to encounters. The six most important game animals in the region, all ungulates, were not encountered at 11-40% of village and control sites or on 29-72% of transects where they were detected by sign. Using the sign methodology, we find that tapirs, one of the terrestrial vertebrates considered most sensitive to overexploitation, are present at many sites where they were never visually detected during distance sampling. We find that this is true for many other species as well. These high rates of under-detection suggest that behavioral changes in hunted populations may affect apparent occurrence and abundance of these populations. Accumulation curves (detection of species on transects) were much steeper for sign for 12 of 16 hunted species than for encounters, but that pattern was reversed for 12 of 16 species unhunted in our area. We conclude that collection of sign data is an efficient and effective method of monitoring hunted vertebrate populations that complements encounter and camera-trapping methods in areas impacted by hunting. Sign surveys may be the most viable method for large-scale, management-oriented studies in remote areas, particularly those focused on community-based wildlife management.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article numbere0152659
JournalPLoS One
Volume11
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1 2016

Fingerprint

Mammals
Sustainable development
mammals
Vertebrates
game animals
vertebrates
Population
Conservation
Animals
Guyana
methodology
Cameras
Sampling
Tapiridae
Food Supply
Monitoring
Population Dynamics
Population Density
wildlife management
Surveys and Questionnaires

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agricultural and Biological Sciences(all)
  • Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology(all)
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Fragoso, J. M. V., Levi, T., Oliveira, L. F. B., Luzar, J. B., Overman, H., Read, J. M., & Silvius, K. M. (2016). Line transect surveys underdetect terrestrial mammals: Implications for the sustainability of subsistence hunting. PLoS One, 11(4), [e0152659]. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0152659

Line transect surveys underdetect terrestrial mammals : Implications for the sustainability of subsistence hunting. / Fragoso, Jose M V; Levi, Taal; Oliveira, Luiz F B; Luzar, Jeffrey B.; Overman, Han; Read, Jane M; Silvius, Kirsten M.

In: PLoS One, Vol. 11, No. 4, e0152659, 01.04.2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Fragoso, Jose M V ; Levi, Taal ; Oliveira, Luiz F B ; Luzar, Jeffrey B. ; Overman, Han ; Read, Jane M ; Silvius, Kirsten M. / Line transect surveys underdetect terrestrial mammals : Implications for the sustainability of subsistence hunting. In: PLoS One. 2016 ; Vol. 11, No. 4.
@article{4e238352353c48079362fcaa5628e8fe,
title = "Line transect surveys underdetect terrestrial mammals: Implications for the sustainability of subsistence hunting",
abstract = "Conservation of Neotropical game species must take into account the livelihood and food security needs of local human populations. Hunting management decisions should therefore rely on abundance and distribution data that are as representative as possible of true population sizes and dynamics. We simultaneously applied a commonly used encounterbased method and an infrequently used sign-based method to estimate hunted vertebrate abundance in a 48,000-km2 indigenous landscape in southern Guyana. Diurnal direct encounter data collected during three years along 216, four-kilometer -long transects consistently under-detected many diurnal and nocturnal mammal species readily detected through sign. Of 32 species analyzed, 31 were detected by both methods; however, encounters did not detect one and under-detected another 12 of the most heavily hunted species relative to sign, while sign under-detected 12 never or rarely collected species relative to encounters. The six most important game animals in the region, all ungulates, were not encountered at 11-40{\%} of village and control sites or on 29-72{\%} of transects where they were detected by sign. Using the sign methodology, we find that tapirs, one of the terrestrial vertebrates considered most sensitive to overexploitation, are present at many sites where they were never visually detected during distance sampling. We find that this is true for many other species as well. These high rates of under-detection suggest that behavioral changes in hunted populations may affect apparent occurrence and abundance of these populations. Accumulation curves (detection of species on transects) were much steeper for sign for 12 of 16 hunted species than for encounters, but that pattern was reversed for 12 of 16 species unhunted in our area. We conclude that collection of sign data is an efficient and effective method of monitoring hunted vertebrate populations that complements encounter and camera-trapping methods in areas impacted by hunting. Sign surveys may be the most viable method for large-scale, management-oriented studies in remote areas, particularly those focused on community-based wildlife management.",
author = "Fragoso, {Jose M V} and Taal Levi and Oliveira, {Luiz F B} and Luzar, {Jeffrey B.} and Han Overman and Read, {Jane M} and Silvius, {Kirsten M.}",
year = "2016",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0152659",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "11",
journal = "PLoS One",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Line transect surveys underdetect terrestrial mammals

T2 - Implications for the sustainability of subsistence hunting

AU - Fragoso, Jose M V

AU - Levi, Taal

AU - Oliveira, Luiz F B

AU - Luzar, Jeffrey B.

AU - Overman, Han

AU - Read, Jane M

AU - Silvius, Kirsten M.

PY - 2016/4/1

Y1 - 2016/4/1

N2 - Conservation of Neotropical game species must take into account the livelihood and food security needs of local human populations. Hunting management decisions should therefore rely on abundance and distribution data that are as representative as possible of true population sizes and dynamics. We simultaneously applied a commonly used encounterbased method and an infrequently used sign-based method to estimate hunted vertebrate abundance in a 48,000-km2 indigenous landscape in southern Guyana. Diurnal direct encounter data collected during three years along 216, four-kilometer -long transects consistently under-detected many diurnal and nocturnal mammal species readily detected through sign. Of 32 species analyzed, 31 were detected by both methods; however, encounters did not detect one and under-detected another 12 of the most heavily hunted species relative to sign, while sign under-detected 12 never or rarely collected species relative to encounters. The six most important game animals in the region, all ungulates, were not encountered at 11-40% of village and control sites or on 29-72% of transects where they were detected by sign. Using the sign methodology, we find that tapirs, one of the terrestrial vertebrates considered most sensitive to overexploitation, are present at many sites where they were never visually detected during distance sampling. We find that this is true for many other species as well. These high rates of under-detection suggest that behavioral changes in hunted populations may affect apparent occurrence and abundance of these populations. Accumulation curves (detection of species on transects) were much steeper for sign for 12 of 16 hunted species than for encounters, but that pattern was reversed for 12 of 16 species unhunted in our area. We conclude that collection of sign data is an efficient and effective method of monitoring hunted vertebrate populations that complements encounter and camera-trapping methods in areas impacted by hunting. Sign surveys may be the most viable method for large-scale, management-oriented studies in remote areas, particularly those focused on community-based wildlife management.

AB - Conservation of Neotropical game species must take into account the livelihood and food security needs of local human populations. Hunting management decisions should therefore rely on abundance and distribution data that are as representative as possible of true population sizes and dynamics. We simultaneously applied a commonly used encounterbased method and an infrequently used sign-based method to estimate hunted vertebrate abundance in a 48,000-km2 indigenous landscape in southern Guyana. Diurnal direct encounter data collected during three years along 216, four-kilometer -long transects consistently under-detected many diurnal and nocturnal mammal species readily detected through sign. Of 32 species analyzed, 31 were detected by both methods; however, encounters did not detect one and under-detected another 12 of the most heavily hunted species relative to sign, while sign under-detected 12 never or rarely collected species relative to encounters. The six most important game animals in the region, all ungulates, were not encountered at 11-40% of village and control sites or on 29-72% of transects where they were detected by sign. Using the sign methodology, we find that tapirs, one of the terrestrial vertebrates considered most sensitive to overexploitation, are present at many sites where they were never visually detected during distance sampling. We find that this is true for many other species as well. These high rates of under-detection suggest that behavioral changes in hunted populations may affect apparent occurrence and abundance of these populations. Accumulation curves (detection of species on transects) were much steeper for sign for 12 of 16 hunted species than for encounters, but that pattern was reversed for 12 of 16 species unhunted in our area. We conclude that collection of sign data is an efficient and effective method of monitoring hunted vertebrate populations that complements encounter and camera-trapping methods in areas impacted by hunting. Sign surveys may be the most viable method for large-scale, management-oriented studies in remote areas, particularly those focused on community-based wildlife management.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84963865328&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84963865328&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0152659

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0152659

M3 - Article

C2 - 27074025

AN - SCOPUS:84963865328

VL - 11

JO - PLoS One

JF - PLoS One

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 4

M1 - e0152659

ER -