Blaming the same-sex victim in HIV-prevention messages: Further examination of the self-protective similarity bias

Brooks B Gump, James A. Kulik, Gary R. Henderson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

It has been demonstrated recently that men will judge their own (threat-relevant) personalities and sexual practices as safer than another man's if that man's HIV status is believed positive compared to negative or is unknown (Gump & Kulik, 1995). The present experiment was designed to expand our understanding of the moderators and mediators of this recently documented "self-protective similarity bias." College students (N= 150) participated in a 2 (Sex of Participant) x 2 (Sex of Model) x 3 (Serostatus: Positive, Negative, Unknown) x 2 (Threat Relevance of Item) factorial design with repeated measures on the last factor. Results indicated that the similarity bias specifically occurs with same-sex models. Analyses of self-ratings and model ratings suggest that the similarity bias was more a function of "blaming" or devaluing the victim than of inflated ratings of the participant's own safety characteristics. Finally, although this bias reduced perceived personal susceptibility and was specific to same-sex models, intentions to adopt safer sexual practices were raised by all HIV-positive models regardless of sex concordance.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)123-132
Number of pages10
JournalBasic and Applied Social Psychology
Volume20
Issue number2
StatePublished - Jun 1998
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

HIV
Personality
Students
Safety

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Psychology(all)
  • Social Psychology

Cite this

Blaming the same-sex victim in HIV-prevention messages : Further examination of the self-protective similarity bias. / Gump, Brooks B; Kulik, James A.; Henderson, Gary R.

In: Basic and Applied Social Psychology, Vol. 20, No. 2, 06.1998, p. 123-132.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{116f16c274cd4cd9b9be811456259cb4,
title = "Blaming the same-sex victim in HIV-prevention messages: Further examination of the self-protective similarity bias",
abstract = "It has been demonstrated recently that men will judge their own (threat-relevant) personalities and sexual practices as safer than another man's if that man's HIV status is believed positive compared to negative or is unknown (Gump & Kulik, 1995). The present experiment was designed to expand our understanding of the moderators and mediators of this recently documented {"}self-protective similarity bias.{"} College students (N= 150) participated in a 2 (Sex of Participant) x 2 (Sex of Model) x 3 (Serostatus: Positive, Negative, Unknown) x 2 (Threat Relevance of Item) factorial design with repeated measures on the last factor. Results indicated that the similarity bias specifically occurs with same-sex models. Analyses of self-ratings and model ratings suggest that the similarity bias was more a function of {"}blaming{"} or devaluing the victim than of inflated ratings of the participant's own safety characteristics. Finally, although this bias reduced perceived personal susceptibility and was specific to same-sex models, intentions to adopt safer sexual practices were raised by all HIV-positive models regardless of sex concordance.",
author = "Gump, {Brooks B} and Kulik, {James A.} and Henderson, {Gary R.}",
year = "1998",
month = "6",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "20",
pages = "123--132",
journal = "Basic and Applied Social Psychology",
issn = "0197-3533",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Blaming the same-sex victim in HIV-prevention messages

T2 - Further examination of the self-protective similarity bias

AU - Gump, Brooks B

AU - Kulik, James A.

AU - Henderson, Gary R.

PY - 1998/6

Y1 - 1998/6

N2 - It has been demonstrated recently that men will judge their own (threat-relevant) personalities and sexual practices as safer than another man's if that man's HIV status is believed positive compared to negative or is unknown (Gump & Kulik, 1995). The present experiment was designed to expand our understanding of the moderators and mediators of this recently documented "self-protective similarity bias." College students (N= 150) participated in a 2 (Sex of Participant) x 2 (Sex of Model) x 3 (Serostatus: Positive, Negative, Unknown) x 2 (Threat Relevance of Item) factorial design with repeated measures on the last factor. Results indicated that the similarity bias specifically occurs with same-sex models. Analyses of self-ratings and model ratings suggest that the similarity bias was more a function of "blaming" or devaluing the victim than of inflated ratings of the participant's own safety characteristics. Finally, although this bias reduced perceived personal susceptibility and was specific to same-sex models, intentions to adopt safer sexual practices were raised by all HIV-positive models regardless of sex concordance.

AB - It has been demonstrated recently that men will judge their own (threat-relevant) personalities and sexual practices as safer than another man's if that man's HIV status is believed positive compared to negative or is unknown (Gump & Kulik, 1995). The present experiment was designed to expand our understanding of the moderators and mediators of this recently documented "self-protective similarity bias." College students (N= 150) participated in a 2 (Sex of Participant) x 2 (Sex of Model) x 3 (Serostatus: Positive, Negative, Unknown) x 2 (Threat Relevance of Item) factorial design with repeated measures on the last factor. Results indicated that the similarity bias specifically occurs with same-sex models. Analyses of self-ratings and model ratings suggest that the similarity bias was more a function of "blaming" or devaluing the victim than of inflated ratings of the participant's own safety characteristics. Finally, although this bias reduced perceived personal susceptibility and was specific to same-sex models, intentions to adopt safer sexual practices were raised by all HIV-positive models regardless of sex concordance.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0032361327&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0032361327&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0032361327

VL - 20

SP - 123

EP - 132

JO - Basic and Applied Social Psychology

JF - Basic and Applied Social Psychology

SN - 0197-3533

IS - 2

ER -